Techniques and Species

Ice Fishing for Big Northern Pike

How to catch big northern pike through the ice with tip-ups, dead baits and quick-strike rigs, plus hole size, trophy benchmarks and safe release tips.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Where big pike hold under the ice
  3. Tip-ups: the main big-pike method
  4. Rigging for big pike
  5. Bait choices
  6. Setting the hook
  7. Jigging for big pike
  8. Hole size
  9. What counts as a trophy
  10. Myths to drop
  11. Handling and release
  12. Cold-air safety for the fish

Short answer

Big pike are most often caught on tip-ups, fished with dead smelt, cisco or herring, or with a live sucker or shiner. Fish the bait near weed edges, on a quick-strike rig with a wire or fluorocarbon leader, and set the hook when a fish takes it.

Where big pike hold under the ice

Pike location changes with the season:

  • First ice: often 4 to 15 ft on weed flats and along weedlines.
  • Mid-winter: big pike often roam, and some hang suspended over deeper basins where cisco are found.
  • Late ice: near spawning bays and creek mouths.

Use a lake map or a flasher to find the weed edges, points and narrows that funnel fish.

Tip-ups: the main big-pike method

A tip-up holds the reel over the hole. When a fish takes line, a signal flag pops up. Spool it with 30 to 50 lb braided line. Braid stays limp and coils less than mono in the cold, which makes it easier to handle on the ice.

Spread several tip-ups 30 to 100 ft apart along a weedline, and set each at a different depth. Line limits vary by state and province, and two or three lines per angler are common, so check your rules first.

Check your bait every so often, and jig it now and then. Once a flag goes up, don’t run toward it. Ice is slippery. Walk over carefully, take hold of the line, and feel what the fish is doing before you set the hook.

Rigging for big pike

  • Leader: 18 to 36 in of 20 to 40 lb fluorocarbon or a thin wire leader. Pike teeth cut light mono.
  • Quick-strike rig: two small trebles, about size 6 to 8, set along the bait. Small hooks hold well and cause less damage than big ones.
  • Line: braid on the reel, with the leader tied to it.

Bait choices

  • Dead baits: smelt, cisco or tullibee, herring and suckers. For big fish, 6 to 12 in is a good size. Dead smelt and cisco often outfish live bait on big pike.
  • Live bait: suckers or golden shiners, about 5 to 10 in. Live bait rules vary, so check them before you buy.
  • Placement: hang the bait 1 to 3 ft off the bottom, or just above the tops of the weeds.

Setting the hook

With a quick-strike rig, set the hook as soon as you feel the take. Waiting too long while a big pike runs can gut-hook it. Timing depends on your rig, so match your wait to the way the hooks are set.

Jigging for big pike

If you prefer to jig, use 1/2 to 1 oz spoons, large swimbaits or Jigging Rap-style lures on a 36 to 42 in medium-heavy rod. Lift in firm strokes, then pause to let the lure settle. Pike often hit on the fall or during the pause.

Hole size

Drill holes at least 8 in across. For fish over about 40 in, 10 in gives you more room to lift the fish safely through the hole.

What counts as a trophy

A common benchmark for a trophy is about 40 in, or 15 lb or more. Size rules vary. Some states and provinces have slot limits or protected sizes, so check before you keep any pike.

Myths to drop

  • “Big pike live only in the shallows.” Large females often suspend deep in mid-winter.
  • “Pike need live bait.” Dead smelt and cisco often do better.
  • “Gaffing is fine.” It is illegal in many places, and it kills fish you plan to release.
  • “Bigger hooks catch bigger pike.” Smaller trebles hook well and do less damage.

Handling and release

Use 10 to 12 in long-nose pliers and a jaw spreader to free hooks. Don’t unhook a pike with your fingers. For the gill-plate grip and how to support a big fish, see how to hold a northern pike.

Cold-air safety for the fish

Below 32°F, a pike’s gills and eyes can freeze within seconds to minutes. Keep the fish out of the air for as short a time as you can. Lay it on wet snow or a wet mat, not bare ice, and release it quickly if you are not keeping it.

For the depth where big pike hold, see the ice fishing depth guide.

The complete guide to techniques and species

Ice Fishing Techniques: Finding Fish at the Right Depth
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →