Short answer
A live crappie minnow, about 1 to 2 in long, is the most reliable all-round bait. Hook it through the back and fish it under a slip bobber or on a deadstick. On active fish, small soft plastics and tiny spoons often do as well or better, so carry both and switch if the bite slows.
How crappies hold
Crappies often suspend about 10 to 30 ft over basins rather than lying on the bottom. They feed upward, so keep your bait a little above them. Find the depth first with a flasher, then set the bait at or just above it. For the depth method, see the ice fishing depth guide.
Live minnows
Use fathead or small shiner minnows, about 1 to 2 in long. Hook the minnow through the back, just under the dorsal fin, on a thin-wire hook sized #6 to #10. This lets it swim level. Fish it under a slip bobber or on a deadstick, with a small split shot about 6 to 12 in above the hook.
On a jig, hook the minnow through the lips instead.
Oversized minnows often get short strikes, so stick with the small size.
Small jigs with a tip
Tungsten jigs in 1/64 to 1/32 oz, or lead jigs in 1/32 to 1/16 oz, work well for crappies. Tip them with a waxworm, a spike or maggot, or a minnow head. Tungsten is denser than lead, so a tungsten jig of the same size sinks faster.
Soft plastics
Small plastics such as 1 to 2 in minnow shapes, tubes and paddle tails often match or beat live bait on active fish. They also stay on the hook well. Fish them on a jig with small movements.
Small spoons
Small spoons in 1/16 to 1/8 oz, tipped with a minnow head, draw crappies in from a distance. They are useful when fish are active and you want to attract them from farther off.
Colour
Glow, white, chartreuse and pink are popular colours. Glow helps at dusk and after dark. The best colour changes with the lake and the day, so try a few.
Line and hookset
Use 2 to 4 lb mono or fluorocarbon. Crappie mouths are thin, which is why they are sometimes called papermouths. Use a light drag and a gentle hookset, or the hook can tear free.
Timing
Crappies often bite best from about an hour before sunset until 1 to 2 hours after dark. Dawn is the second-best window. For more on timing, see which time is best for ice fishing.
Common mistakes
- Believing there is one best crappie bait. The best bait changes with the fish’s mood, the light and the lake.
- Using big minnows. Oversized baits get short strikes.
- Fishing the bottom. Most crappies suspend.
- Assuming live bait always wins. Plastics can outfish minnows on an active school.
Night safety
If you fish after dark, carry a headlamp and ice picks, and mark the route back to shore. Plan the walk back before you start. For jigging with plastics and light lures, see how to jig through the ice.