Lake Mendota, in Madison, has one of the longest lake-ice records in the world. Its ice records go back to the 1850s. The official ice-on date is a useful record, but it isn’t a safety call. Thickness varies a lot across the lake, and nobody measures it lake-wide.
Why “frozen” doesn’t mean safe
Ice-on on Mendota is determined by observers who check the lake from several spots, using a rule that the lake is closed when about half of it is covered. For Mendota, observers also check whether a boat can row between Picnic Point and Maple Bluff. An ice-on date isn’t official until the lake has stayed closed for at least a full day.
None of that tells you how thick the ice is. An official ice-on date doesn’t mean the ice is safe to walk on.
Typical ice-on is in mid to late December, and ice-off is usually late March to early April, though it varies widely. Mendota freezes later than nearby Monona and Wingra because it’s larger and deeper.
Ice has been lasting a shorter time over the long record. Average ice duration has fallen from roughly four months in the 1850s to roughly three months in recent decades. Individual years still vary a lot. In the 2021–22 season, for example, Mendota froze on January 7 and opened on April 2, about 85 days later.
No lake-wide thickness number
Ice thickness isn’t officially measured across the lake. Anglers rely on local bait shops and their own checks. The Wisconsin DNR doesn’t certify the ice as safe.
Check thickness often, as the ice fishing safety guide explains. A common habit is to drill a test hole every 100 to 150 feet as you move out, and to check again as you go. Snow-covered ice is weaker and thickens more slowly than clear ice, so don’t treat snow ice like clear ice.
Thin spots to avoid
Currents keep ice thin near inflows and outflows all winter. Watch for thin spots at:
- The Yahara River inflow near Cherokee Marsh.
- The Pheasant Branch inflow.
- The Yahara outlet near the Tenney Park locks.
- Storm outfalls and springs.
Pressure cracks form off Picnic Point and near bridges and outlets, so keep clear of them.
Where anglers fish
Popular spots include University Bay, Second Point and Picnic Point, Governor’s Island, Maple Bluff, Warner Bay and Fox Bluff.
The lake holds walleye, yellow perch, northern pike, bluegill, crappie, cisco and white bass. Mendota is the largest lake in the Yahara chain, at about 9,800 acres and up to about 83 feet deep, so it’s a big lake to cover on foot.
Rules to check
- Wisconsin allows three lines per angler through the ice.
- Shanties need the owner’s name and address on them.
- Shanty removal dates are set by region. Check the current date before you go.
For another Wisconsin option, see Lake Winnebago. For a wider look at ice fishing lakes across North America, see our guide to the best ice fishing lakes.