Lake St. Clair is shallow, and anglers fish it mostly for yellow perch. Western Lake Erie is known for walleye and for island ice houses. The two lakes ice up differently, and Erie has a history of floe strandings you should know about before you go.
Lake St. Clair: perch and bays
Lake St. Clair covers about 430 square miles and averages roughly 11 feet deep. A dredged shipping channel runs through it at about 27 feet.
Ice fishing centers on the bays. On the Michigan side, Anchor Bay, near New Baltimore and Fair Haven, and the Lake St. Clair Metropark area are common starting points. On the Canadian side, Mitchell’s Bay and Belle River are used.
Yellow perch are the main target. Walleye and northern pike are also caught, and bluegill and crappie show up in canals and marinas. The current from the St. Clair River keeps parts of the lake thin, even where the bays look solid.
Lake Erie: western basin and island ice houses
Lake Erie is the shallowest of the Great Lakes, averaging about 62 feet. Its western basin is shallower still, averaging about 24 feet, and it freezes first. Ice cover on Erie can exceed 90 percent in cold winters, but it stays low in mild winters, so the ice varies widely from year to year.
Western Erie’s ice fishing centers on the islands, such as South Bass (Put-in-Bay), Middle Bass and Kelleys, and on the reefs near Port Clinton and Catawba. Walleye are the main target, often in 20 to 30 feet of water over reefs and mud, with yellow perch as a secondary species.
Ice houses and shanties
Island guides rent heated ice houses. They often move clients out to the fishing grounds by airboat, ATV or plane. Renting from a guide puts the ice and the logistics in experienced hands, which matters on Erie.
Michigan shanties must carry the owner’s name and address, or a DNR customer ID. Removal dates vary by region, so check the current date before you go. Michigan and Ohio also set different line limits, so check both if you fish across the state line.
A Michigan licence doesn’t cover the Ontario side of Erie or St. Clair. You need the right licence for the water you’re on.
Floe risk on Erie
Offshore wind, which blows from the shore out over the ice, is the main cause of floe strandings on Lake Erie. Shore ice can break free in an offshore wind even when it’s thick.
In February 2009, about 134 anglers were rescued from a floe that broke away near Port Clinton. One person died. The lesson is simple: watch the wind forecast before you go out, and watch it again while you’re on the ice.
Carry a spud bar, picks, a float coat and a way to call for help, and know the self-rescue steps before you go. On the St. Clair River, ice jams can also flood shoreline homes, so stay off river ice.
Where is the best ice fishing right now?
We can’t give live conditions, and Erie and St. Clair can change within days. Ask local island guides, bait shops and clubs for recent reports. For the broader Lake Michigan picture, see can you ice fish in Lake Michigan.
For a wider look at ice fishing lakes across North America, see our guide to the best ice fishing lakes.