Yes, but almost only in protected bays and harbors. The open main lake rarely freezes solid, so don’t count on it. Stick to sheltered water, check the ice as you go, and follow the rules of the state whose waters you’re on.
Where ice fishing works
Sheltered bays and harbors are where ice forms, and where anglers go. Ice usually forms in the bays around January, and in a cold winter some bays stay fishable into March.
Green Bay, the top area in Wisconsin
Green Bay is the best-known ice fishing area on Lake Michigan. Anglers target walleye, yellow perch, whitefish and northern pike. Access points include Suamico, Bayshore, Sturgeon Bay and Little Sturgeon Bay. Whitefish are a major winter fishery here, often caught in 30 to 60 feet of water near Sturgeon Bay.
Upper Peninsula bays
Little Bay de Noc and Big Bay de Noc, in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula near Escanaba and Gladstone, are top walleye and perch ice fisheries.
Other Michigan and harbor options
Grand Traverse Bay can produce whitefish, lake trout and perch, but only when its East and West arms freeze, which doesn’t happen every year. Harbors such as Milwaukee, Racine, Waukegan and Michigan City can offer brown trout or perch in cold winters, though it varies.
Harbor and pier ice near warm-water discharges can stay thin all winter, so don’t assume the ice is solid just because the harbor looks frozen. Lake St. Clair and Lake Erie have their own ice patterns, covered in our Lake St. Clair and Lake Erie guide.
Why the open lake doesn’t freeze
Lake Michigan is big and deep. Ice cover peaks at roughly 40 percent of the lake in a typical winter. In the coldest years it has reached roughly 93 percent, as in 1977 and 2014. Wind and seiches, the back-and-forth sloshing of the water, can shift, crack and open the ice suddenly.
Safety on Lake Michigan ice
- Many sources recommend at least 4 to 5 inches of clear, solid ice before walking. Treat that as a minimum, and test the ice as you go with a spud or chisel.
- Bay ice can be thick near shore and dangerous a short distance out.
- Watch offshore winds. Anglers have been stranded on floes on Green Bay.
- River mouths, such as the Fox, Menominee and Escanaba, stay thin because of the current.
- Marinas with circulating pumps can have hidden soft spots.
Licences and lines
You generally need the licence of the state whose waters you fish: Wisconsin, Michigan, Illinois or Indiana. Line limits also vary by state, so check the current rules for the state whose water you’re on before you set up.