History and Culture

How Ice Fishing Differs from Open-Water Fishing

Ice fishing uses short rods, vertical jigging and moving holes instead of a boat. Here is how gear, fish behavior and safety differ from open water.

On this page
  1. Water and fish behavior
  2. Side-by-side: open water vs ice
  3. Vertical presentation
  4. Moving: hole-hopping
  5. Passive gear
  6. Electronics
  7. Shelters and heat
  8. Rules differ
  9. Safety: ice replaces boat safety

Ice fishing is mostly vertical. You drop a short rod straight down a hole rather than casting from a boat. Fish move more slowly in cold water, so smaller baits and subtler jigging often work better. Holes replace the boat: you drill, fish, and drill again when you move.

Water and fish behavior

Water under the ice ranges from about 32°F at the ice to about 39°F (4°C) near the bottom of deeper lakes. Cold water slows fish metabolism, so fish feed more slowly. They do not stop feeding in winter. Many feed in shallow water at first ice and late ice. Snow cover also cuts light, which affects where and when fish feed.

Side-by-side: open water vs ice

Open water Ice
Rod length About 6 to 7 feet About 24 to 36 inches
How you present the bait Casting and retrieving Dropping it straight down the hole
Line Varies by target Lighter for panfish (about 2 to 4 lb); about 6 to 10 lb for walleye
How you move Trolling or drifting Drilling new holes (hole-hopping)
Electronics Fish-finder graph Flasher or forward-facing sonar
Access Boat On foot, by snowmobile or ATV, or by vehicle
Main gear investment Boat Shelter and heater

Vertical presentation

On the ice, you work the lure up and down under the hole. Jigging can be active, with small lifts and drops, or passive, with the bait left still. Active jigging often catches more fish than waiting does.

Open-water lures can work vertically too. Spoons and blade baits are examples, so you do not need a special lure for every method.

Moving: hole-hopping

Anglers often drill several holes and move until they find fish. This is called hole-hopping, or run-and-gun. It replaces trolling and drifting, but it means more drilling and more effort.

Passive gear

Tip-ups and deadsticks let you fish several holes at once, within legal line limits. A tip-up’s flag signals a bite. How many lines you can use depends on the state.

Electronics

A flasher shows fish directly below you in real time. Forward-facing sonar shows fish to the side of the hole, too. Both help you decide whether to stay where you are or move on.

Shelters and heat

On the ice, a shelter and a heater replace the boat as your main gear investment. Heated shelters need a CO detector and ventilation. Wind and cold will shape how comfortable a day feels, so plan for them.

Rules differ

Ice fishing has its own rules. Line limits, shelter rules and seasons can differ from open-water rules, so check current regulations for both.

Safety: ice replaces boat safety

On the ice, ice safety takes the place of boat safety. The commonly cited minimum for walking is 4 inches of clear ice. Carry ice picks, fish with a partner and check the ice before you walk on it.

Late-winter oxygen can also be a problem. In shallow, weedy lakes, low oxygen (winterkill) can harm fish. Fish do best on lakes with enough oxygen, so it’s worth asking locals about the lake’s condition.

For the gear words you’ll hear on the ice, see ice fishing terms. For the species you can catch through the ice, see what fish do you catch while ice fishing?.

The complete guide to history and culture

The History and Origins of Ice Fishing
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →